Cutler Capital Management, LLC

In its 13F for Q1 2024 (holdings as of March 31, 2024, filed May 14, 2024), Cutler Capital Management, LLC reported 84 stock positions worth $205.6 million. Its top holding was Metlife (MET) at 6.2% of the portfolio, followed by Agnico Eagle Mines (AEM, 4.3%) and Merck (MRK, 4.2%). Compared with Q4 2023, it opened 11 new positions, sold out of 6, added to 43 and reduced 19. The biggest buy was Metlife (MET, shares +0%) and the biggest sale an exit from Bankflorida Bancorp (BKFL).

Most Recent 13F
Q2 2026
Location
WORCESTER, MA
CIK
0001353098
Portfolio Value
$205.6M (Q1 2024)
SEC Filing
0001353098-24-000007 ↗ filed May 14, 2024

Holdings Value

0$100.0M$200.0M$300.0M$400.0M Q1 2024: $205.6M $205.6M Q1 2024 Q2 2024: $206.7M Q2 2024 Q3 2024: $229.5M Q3 2024 Q4 2024: $222.8M Q4 2024 Q1 2025: $225.2M Q1 2025 Q2 2025: $233.8M Q2 2025 Q3 2025: $250.9M Q3 2025 Q4 2025: $270.8M Q4 2025 Q1 2026: $297.9M Q1 2026 Q2 2026: $315.8M Q2 2026

Holdings 84 stocks · $205.6M

MET Metlife Inc. 6.19% 171,626 $12.7M Add +0.1%
AEM Agnico Eagle Mines Ltd. 4.31% 148,426 $8.9M Add +2.3%
MRK Merck & Co. Inc. 4.17% 64,964 $8.6M Reduce -0.8%
BG Bunge Global SA 4.00% 80,161 $8.2M Add +0.9%
TSBK Timberland Bancorp Inc. 3.90% 298,141 $8.0M Add +2.2%
EXSR Exchange Bank Santa Rosa Cal 3.86% 76,254 $7.9M Reduce -0.3%
SHEL Shell PLC-ADR 3.53% 108,258 $7.3M Add +0.8%
ET Energy Transfer LP 3.44% 449,503 $7.1M Add +1.9%
PFE Pfizer Inc. 3.13% 232,128 $6.4M Add +3.3%
FENY Fidelity MSCI Energy Index 3.06% 243,413 $6.3M Add +5.2%
FBIZ First Business Financial Ser 2.79% 152,863 $5.7M Add +0.2%
VTRS Viatris Inc. 2.74% 472,604 $5.6M Add +2.2%
SBFG SB Financial Group Inc. filed as SB FINL GROUP INC 2.68% 400,312 $5.5M Add +0.0%
WY Weyerhaeuser Co. 2.64% 150,914 $5.4M Add +0.3%
PKBK Parke Bancorp Inc. 2.58% 308,071 $5.3M Add +0.1%
LFGP Ledyard Financial Group Inc. 2.45% 329,146 $5.0M Reduce -0.7%
VICI Vici Properties Inc. filed as VICI PPTYS INC 1.91% 131,931 $3.9M Add +5.0%
XRN Global Medical REIT Inc. 1.83% 430,444 $3.8M Add +4.0%
ALRS Alerus Financial Corp. 1.68% 158,201 $3.5M Add +0.5%
BMBN Benchmark Bankshares Inc. 1.65% 159,000 $3.4M Add +11.2%
CWBC Community West Bancshares 1.59% 211,520 $3.3M Reduce -9.9%
FXNC First National Corp. 1.59% 201,058 $3.3M Reduce -0.8%
CPKF Chesapeake Finl SHS Inc. 1.49% 173,000 $3.1M No change
BORT Bank of Botetourt Buchanan V filed as BANK BOTETOURT 1.45% 104,974 $3.0M Add +1.1%
ACI Albertsons Cos Inc. Class A 1.42% 135,969 $2.9M Add +7.9%
CSBB CSB Bancorp Inc. 1.36% 69,850 $2.8M Add +0.7%
PTBS Potomac Bancshares Inc. 1.35% 185,868 $2.8M Add +0.9%
SFL SFL Corp. Ltd. 1.31% 204,690 $2.7M Reduce -0.4%
CTO Cto Realty Growth Inc. filed as CTO RLTY GROWTH INC NEW 1.29% 156,969 $2.7M Add +14.8%
VZ Verizon Communications Inc. 1.28% 62,721 $2.6M Add +0.9%
APLE Apple Hospitality REIT Inc. 1.24% 155,223 $2.5M Add +16.6%
AIG American International Group 1.24% 32,500 $2.5M No change
ENR Energizer Holdings Inc. 1.20% 83,971 $2.5M Reduce -1.4%
LXP LXP Industrial Trust 1.14% 260,774 $2.4M Reduce -0.3%
FMBM F & M Bank Corp. filed as F&M BANCORP 1.12% 133,914 $2.3M No change
IFF Intl Flavors & Fragrances filed as INTERNATIONAL FLAVORS&FRAGRA 1.07% 25,602 $2.2M Reduce -1.4%
MNSB Mainstreet Bancshares Inc. 1.04% 118,296 $2.1M Add +7.3%
SOBS Solvay Bank Solvay N Y 0.93% 72,895 $1.9M Reduce -0.4%
ABCB Ameris Bancorp 0.89% 37,750 $1.8M Reduce -10.4%
MFGI Merchants Financial Group Inc. 0.84% 73,000 $1.7M Add +1.0%
FSBH FSBH Corp. 0.82% 210,000 $1.7M Add +10.7%
TSN Tyson Foods Inc. Class A 0.79% 27,824 $1.6M Reduce -0.3%
MOAT Vaneck Morningstar Wide Moat 0.71% 16,234 $1.5M Add +10.2%
VOO Vanguard S&P 500 ETF 0.68% 2,928 $1.4M Add +19.9%
FCCO First Community Corp. 0.65% 76,500 $1.3M No change
FNCB FNCB Bancorp Inc. 0.63% 212,447 $1.3M Reduce -1.6%
MCHN McHenry Bancorp Inc. 0.62% 33,515 $1.3M New
T AT&T Inc. 0.57% 67,027 $1.2M Reduce -0.7%
BANC Banc of California Inc. 0.52% 69,750 $1.1M Add +46.1%
EBMT Eagle Bancorp Montana Inc. 0.44% 70,985 $911K Add +0.3%
FISI Financial Institutions Inc. 0.42% 45,683 $860K Add +0.1%
GDX Vaneck Gold Miners ETF 0.41% 26,987 $853K Add +14.0%
VGM Invesco Trust for Investmen 0.41% 86,117 $849K No change
TTE Totalenergies SE -Spon ADR 0.40% 12,000 $826K New
ABBV Abbvie Inc. 0.34% 3,849 $701K Add +0.9%
MPT Medical Properties Trust Inc. 0.34% 148,610 $698K Add +4.7%
FRAF Franklin Financial Services 0.30% 23,907 $626K Reduce -1.1%
BRK.B Berkshire Hathaway Inc. Class B 0.27% 1,336 $562K No change
FLIC First of Long Island Corp. filed as FIRST LONG IS CORP 0.26% 48,137 $534K Add +0.9%
MSFT Microsoft Corp. 0.25% 1,241 $522K Add +18.0%
HWC Hancock Whitney Corp. 0.24% 10,802 $497K Add +0.7%
SSB Southstate Bank Corp. 0.23% 5,654 $481K Add +0.6%
CZBT Citizens Bancorp of Virginia 0.23% 18,650 $480K No change
MTB M & T Bank Corp. filed as M & T BK CORP 0.21% 3,035 $441K Add +0.9%
IUSV iShares Core S&P U.S. Value 0.20% 4,550 $412K Reduce -5.2%
QABA First Trust Nasdaq Aba Cbif 0.20% 8,804 $410K Reduce -1.1%
SPY SS SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust-US 0.17% 660 $345K No change
SBCF Seacoast Banking Corp. 0.13% 10,826 $275K Add +0.7%
KR Kroger Co. 0.12% 4,157 $238K Add +0.2%
BRBS Blue Ridge Bankshares Inc. 0.11% 84,195 $226K Add +26.8%
SCHV Schwab US Large-Cap Value 0.11% 2,967 $225K Reduce -19.1%
TGNA Tegna Inc. 0.09% 12,800 $191K New
CNH CNH Industrial NV 0.08% 12,500 $162K New
AMZN Amazon.com Inc. 0.08% 880 $159K No change
SCHF Schwab Intl Equity ETF 0.07% 3,779 $147K No change
TV Grupo Televisa SA-Spon ADR 0.06% 40,800 $131K New
MOTG Vaneck Mstar GL Wide Moat 0.06% 3,225 $118K No change
IBM Intl Business Machines Corp. filed as INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS MACHS 0.06% 611 $117K New
WIW Western Asst Infl-LNK Opp 0.06% 13,276 $115K New
IWS iShares Russell Mid-Cap Valu 0.05% 886 $111K New
WBD Warner Bros Discovery Inc. 0.05% 12,463 $109K Reduce -1.4%
LOW Lowe's Cos Inc. 0.05% 420 $107K New
JCI Johnson Controls Internation 0.05% 1,538 $100K New
JPM JPMorgan Chase & Co. 0.05% 500 $100K New
Other holdings (25): bonds, preferreds, convertibles and warrants · $48.8M (not counted above)
SecurityClassShares / PrincipalValueChange
HCI GROUP INC (HCI 4.75 06/01/42) NOTE 4.750% 6/0 · principal 4,090,000$6.3MReduce -5.3%
KIMCO REALTY CORP (KIM 7.25 PERP N) DP CV CL N 7.25% 91,537$5.2MNew
PPL CAPITAL FUNDING INC (PPL 2.875 03/15/28) NOTE 2.875% 3/1 · principal 4,530,000$4.3MNew
JAZZ INVESTMENTS I LTD (JAZZ 2 06/15/26) NOTE 2.000% 6/1 · principal 4,195,000$4.2MNew
INNOVIVA INC (INVA 2.5 08/15/25) NOTE 2.500% 8/1 · principal 3,835,000$4.1MReduce -0.7%
FLAGSTAR BANK NA (FLG 6 11/01/51) UNIT 05/07/2051 103,095$3.4MReduce -1.4%
LIBERTY MEDIA CORP (FWONK 2.25 08/15/27) NOTE 2.250% 8/1 · principal 2,485,000$2.5MAdd +8.0%
NRG ENERGY INC (NRG 2.75 06/01/48) DBCV 2.750% 6/0 · principal 1,375,000$2.3MReduce -37.6%
FORD MOTOR COMPANY (F 0 03/15/26) NOTE 3/1 · principal 2,017,000$2.1MAdd +1623.9%
EPR PROPERTIES (EPR 5.75 PERP C) PFD C CV 5.75% 97,245$1.8MAdd +37.0%
ETSY INC (ETSY 0.125 09/01/27) NOTE 0.125% 9/0 · principal 2,015,000$1.7MNew
JAZZ INVESTMENTS I LTD (JAZZ 1.5 08/15/24) NOTE 1.500% 8/1 · principal 1,540,000$1.5MAdd +14.1%
EURONET WORLDWIDE INC (EEFT 0.75 03/15/49) NOTE 0.750% 3/1 · principal 1,544,000$1.5MAdd +348.8%
LCI INDUSTRIES (LCII 1.125 05/15/26) NOTE 1.125% 5/1 · principal 1,425,000$1.4MNew
CLARIVATE PLC (CLVT 5.25 06/01/24 A) 5.25% PFD CONV A 41,485$1.2MNew
STARWOOD PROPERTY TRUST (STWD 6.75 07/15/27) NOTE 6.750% 7/1 · principal 985,000$1.0MReduce -1.0%
ALLIANT ENERGY CORP (LNT 3.875 03/15/26) NOTE 3.875% 3/1 · principal 1,000,000$984KNew
LYFT INC (LYFT 1.5 05/15/25) NOTE 1.500% 5/1 · principal 845,000$823KReduce -1.7%
AIRBNB INC (ABNB 0 03/15/26) NOTE 3/1 · principal 670,000$623KNew
BANC OF CALIFORNIA INC (BANC V7.75 PERP F) NON 13F SECURITY 25,150$579KReduce -0.8%
CHEGG INC (CHGG 0.125 03/15/25) NOTE 0.125% 3/1 · principal 290,000$270KNo change
SPOTIFY USA INC (SPOT 0 03/15/26) NOTE 3/1 · principal 290,000$266KNo change
EXPEDIA GROUP INC (EXPE 0 02/15/26) NOTE 2/1 · principal 275,000$253KNo change
EZCORP INC (EZPW 2.875 07/01/24) NOTE 2.875% 7/0 · principal 215,000$238KNo change
GREENBRIER COS INC (GBX 2.875 04/15/28) NOTE 2.875% 4/1 · principal 117,000$130KNo change

Total filed on the 13F, all lines: $254.4M.

Portfolio Sells Q4 2023 → Q1 2024

BKFL Bankflorida Bancorp Inc. Sold out 0.00% −0.58
MCHENRY BANCORP Sold out 0.00% −0.57
FXNC First National Corp. Reduce -0.8% 1.59% −0.56
CWBC Community West Bancshares Reduce -9.9% 1.59% −0.40
MCBI Mountain Commerce Bancorp Inc. Sold out 0.00% −0.34
KEY Keycorp Sold out 0.00% −0.34
LFGP Ledyard Financial Group Inc. Reduce -0.7% 2.45% −0.28
ABCB Ameris Bancorp Reduce -10.4% 0.89% −0.20
TRAIX T Rowe PR Captl Apprec-I Sold out 0.00% −0.16
LXP LXP Industrial Trust Reduce -0.3% 1.14% −0.12
ENR Energizer Holdings Inc. Reduce -1.4% 1.20% −0.11
FNCB FNCB Bancorp Inc. Reduce -1.6% 0.63% −0.09
FRAF Franklin Financial Services Reduce -1.1% 0.30% −0.07
IYR iShares US Real Estate ETF Sold out 0.00% −0.05
SOBS Solvay Bank Solvay N Y Reduce -0.4% 0.93% −0.04
WBD Warner Bros Discovery Inc. Reduce -1.4% 0.05% −0.02
QABA First Trust Nasdaq Aba Cbif Reduce -1.1% 0.20% −0.02
SCHV Schwab US Large-Cap Value Reduce -19.1% 0.11% −0.02
IUSV iShares Core S&P U.S. Value Reduce -5.2% 0.20% +0.00
T AT&T Inc. Reduce -0.7% 0.57% +0.02
IFF Intl Flavors & Fragrances Reduce -1.4% 1.07% +0.05
TSN Tyson Foods Inc. Class A Reduce -0.3% 0.79% +0.06
EXSR Exchange Bank Santa Rosa Cal Reduce -0.3% 3.86% +0.09
SFL SFL Corp. Ltd. Reduce -0.4% 1.31% +0.18
MRK Merck & Co. Inc. Reduce -0.8% 4.17% +0.69

Portfolio Buys Q4 2023 → Q1 2024

MET Metlife Inc. Add +0.1% 6.19% +0.66
MCHN McHenry Bancorp Inc. New 0.62% +0.62
ET Energy Transfer LP Add +1.9% 3.44% +0.47
FENY Fidelity MSCI Energy Index Add +5.2% 3.06% +0.47
AEM Agnico Eagle Mines Ltd. Add +2.3% 4.31% +0.43
TTE Totalenergies SE -Spon ADR New 0.40% +0.40
VTRS Viatris Inc. Add +2.2% 2.74% +0.30
BANC Banc of California Inc. Add +46.1% 0.52% +0.20
VOO Vanguard S&P 500 ETF Add +19.9% 0.68% +0.16
APLE Apple Hospitality REIT Inc. Add +16.6% 1.24% +0.16
CTO Cto Realty Growth Inc. Add +14.8% 1.29% +0.14
VZ Verizon Communications Inc. Add +0.9% 1.28% +0.14
FSBH FSBH Corp. Add +10.7% 0.82% +0.10
MOAT Vaneck Morningstar Wide Moat Add +10.2% 0.71% +0.10
TGNA Tegna Inc. New 0.09% +0.09
CSBB CSB Bancorp Inc. Add +0.7% 1.36% +0.09
BG Bunge Global SA Add +0.9% 4.00% +0.09
WY Weyerhaeuser Co. Add +0.3% 2.64% +0.09
SHEL Shell PLC-ADR Add +0.8% 3.53% +0.08
CNH CNH Industrial NV New 0.08% +0.08
TV Grupo Televisa SA-Spon ADR New 0.06% +0.06
MSFT Microsoft Corp. Add +18.0% 0.25% +0.06
GDX Vaneck Gold Miners ETF Add +14.0% 0.41% +0.06
IBM Intl Business Machines Corp. New 0.06% +0.06
WIW Western Asst Infl-LNK Opp New 0.06% +0.06
IWS iShares Russell Mid-Cap Valu New 0.05% +0.05
ABBV Abbvie Inc. Add +0.9% 0.34% +0.05
LOW Lowe's Cos Inc. New 0.05% +0.05
JCI Johnson Controls Internation New 0.05% +0.05
JPM JPMorgan Chase & Co. New 0.05% +0.05
KR Kroger Co. Add +0.2% 0.12% +0.02
PTBS Potomac Bancshares Inc. Add +0.9% 1.35% +0.02
MTB M & T Bank Corp. Add +0.9% 0.21% +0.01
BORT Bank of Botetourt Buchanan V Add +1.1% 1.45% +0.01
BRBS Blue Ridge Bankshares Inc. Add +26.8% 0.11% +0.01
BMBN Benchmark Bankshares Inc. Add +11.2% 1.65% +0.01
MFGI Merchants Financial Group Inc. Add +1.0% 0.84% +0.01
ACI Albertsons Cos Inc. Class A Add +7.9% 1.42% +0.01
SSB Southstate Bank Corp. Add +0.6% 0.23% +0.00
MPT Medical Properties Trust Inc. Add +4.7% 0.34% 0.00
HWC Hancock Whitney Corp. Add +0.7% 0.24% −0.01
SBCF Seacoast Banking Corp. Add +0.7% 0.13% −0.02
PFE Pfizer Inc. Add +3.3% 3.13% −0.02
ALRS Alerus Financial Corp. Add +0.5% 1.68% −0.04
VICI Vici Properties Inc. Add +5.0% 1.91% −0.04
FLIC First of Long Island Corp. Add +0.9% 0.26% −0.05
FISI Financial Institutions Inc. Add +0.1% 0.42% −0.06
EBMT Eagle Bancorp Montana Inc. Add +0.3% 0.44% −0.10
FBIZ First Business Financial Ser Add +0.2% 2.79% −0.19
SBFG SB Financial Group Inc. Add +0.0% 2.68% −0.28

Notes & Other Activity Q4 2023 → Q1 2024

HCI GROUP INC (HCI 4.75 06/01/42) NOTE 4.750% 6/0 · principal Reduce -5.3% 4,090,000 $6.3M
KIMCO REALTY CORP (KIM 7.25 PERP N) DP CV CL N 7.25% New 91,537 $5.2M
RPT REALTY (KIM 7.25 PERP D) 7.25 PFD D CONV Sold out 87,231 $5.0Mbefore exit
PPL CAPITAL FUNDING INC (PPL 2.875 03/15/28) NOTE 2.875% 3/1 · principal New 4,530,000 $4.3M
JAZZ INVESTMENTS I LTD (JAZZ 2 06/15/26) NOTE 2.000% 6/1 · principal New 4,195,000 $4.2M
INNOVIVA INC (INVA 2.5 08/15/25) NOTE 2.500% 8/1 · principal Reduce -0.7% 3,835,000 $4.1M
FLAGSTAR BANK NA (FLG 6 11/01/51) UNIT 05/07/2051 Reduce -1.4% 103,095 $3.4M
LIBERTY MEDIA CORP (FWONK 2.25 08/15/27) NOTE 2.250% 8/1 · principal Add +8.0% 2,485,000 $2.5M
NRG ENERGY INC (NRG 2.75 06/01/48) DBCV 2.750% 6/0 · principal Reduce -37.6% 1,375,000 $2.3M
FORD MOTOR COMPANY (F 0 03/15/26) NOTE 3/1 · principal Add +1623.9% 2,017,000 $2.1M
EPR PROPERTIES (EPR 5.75 PERP C) PFD C CV 5.75% Add +37.0% 97,245 $1.8M
GREAT AJAX CORP (RPT 7.25 04/30/24) 7.25 CV SR NT 24 Sold out 68,835 $1.7Mbefore exit
ETSY INC (ETSY 0.125 09/01/27) NOTE 0.125% 9/0 · principal New 2,015,000 $1.7M
JAZZ INVESTMENTS I LTD (JAZZ 1.5 08/15/24) NOTE 1.500% 8/1 · principal Add +14.1% 1,540,000 $1.5M
EURONET WORLDWIDE INC (EEFT 0.75 03/15/49) NOTE 0.750% 3/1 · principal Add +348.8% 1,544,000 $1.5M
LCI INDUSTRIES (LCII 1.125 05/15/26) NOTE 1.125% 5/1 · principal New 1,425,000 $1.4M
ETSY DEB · principal Sold out 1,525,000 $1.3Mbefore exit
CLARIVATE PLC (CLVT 5.25 06/01/24 A) 5.25% PFD CONV A New 41,485 $1.2M
STARWOOD PROPERTY TRUST (STWD 6.75 07/15/27) NOTE 6.750% 7/1 · principal Reduce -1.0% 985,000 $1.0M
ALLIANT ENERGY CORP (LNT 3.875 03/15/26) NOTE 3.875% 3/1 · principal New 1,000,000 $984K
VIAVI SOLUTIONS INC (VIAV 1 03/01/24) NOTE 1.000% 3/0 · principal Sold out 985,000 $963Kbefore exit
LYFT INC (LYFT 1.5 05/15/25) NOTE 1.500% 5/1 · principal Reduce -1.7% 845,000 $823K
AIRBNB INC (ABNB 0 03/15/26) NOTE 3/1 · principal New 670,000 $623K
BANC OF CALIFORNIA INC (BANC V7.75 PERP F) NON 13F SECURITY Reduce -0.8% 25,150 $579K
HARBOR CUSTOM DEV INC (HCDI 8 PERP A) 8% CONV PFD SR A Sold out 522,975 $497Kbefore exit
ARES CAPITAL CORP (ARCC 4.625 03/01/24) NOTE 4.625% 3/0 · principal Sold out 295,000 $304Kbefore exit
WESTERN DIGITAL CORP (WDC 1.5 02/01/24) NOTE 1.500% 2/0 · principal Sold out 210,000 $209Kbefore exit
GUIDEWIRE SOFTWARE INC (GWRE 1.25 03/15/25) NOTE 1.250% 3/1 · principal Sold out 165,000 $181Kbefore exit
PARSONS CORP (PSN 0.25 08/15/25) NOTE 0.250% 8/1 · principal Sold out 100,000 $143Kbefore exit
CHEVRON BOFA DEB · principal Sold out 94,000 $106Kbefore exit

Bonds, preferreds, convertibles and warrants; not part of the stock holdings or percentages above.

All Filings

QuarterPositions13F Reported ValueTop Holdings
Q2 2026 100$315.8MAEM, MET, CTO, TSBK, EXSR
Q1 2026 91$297.9MAEM, MET, CTO, TSBK, EXSR
Q4 2025 94$270.8MAEM, MET, CTO, TSBK, EXSR
Q3 2025 95$250.9MAEM, MET, CTO, TSBK, EXSR
Q2 2025 90$233.8MAEM, MET, CTO, TSBK, EXSR
Q1 2025 87$225.2MAEM, MET, TSBK, EXSR, SBFG
Q4 2024Amended 85$222.8MMET, AEM, TSBK, ET, EXSR
Q3 2024 83$229.5MMET, AEM, TSBK, EXSR, SBFG
Q2 2024 83$206.7MMET, AEM, BG, TSBK, SHEL
Q1 2024 84$205.6MMET, AEM, MRK, BG, TSBK